Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Prime Webinar GroupPrime Webinar Group

Editor's Pick

Latest Attempt to Restore Financial Privacy: the Saving Privacy Act

Norbert Michel, Jennifer J. Schulp, and Nicholas Anthony

lee

On Wednesday, September 25, 2024, Senator Mike Lee (R‑UT) introduced the Saving Privacy Act (SPA), a bill that contains major reforms to strengthen Americans’ financial privacy. As many experts discussed at our annual conference two weeks ago, financial privacy has been under fire for the last 50 years, largely because of the Bank Secrecy Act of 1970 (and its many amendments).

A massive federal anti-money laundering regime is now based on this outdated law, but the whole thing is poorly designed, too costly, and ineffective. It also rests on shaky legal grounds, endangering Americans’ financial privacy by weakening the protections they’re supposed to have from the Fourth Amendment. Unfortunately, the United States government has spent decades expanding this regime and encouraging other countries to adopt a similar approach.

What the US should do, instead, is lead the way by enhancing financial privacy and encouraging other countries to adopt the kinds of protections Americans had before 1970. The Saving Privacy Act is a positive step in that direction. 

Much like Rep. John Rose’s (R‑TN) Bank Privacy Reform Act, Senator Lee’s bill would essentially end the practice of requiring banks to act as law enforcement agents and would prevent law enforcement agencies from accessing customers’ financial records without first obtaining a valid warrant. (Unlike Rep. Rose’s bill, Sen. Lee’s bill addresses privacy issues outside the Bank Secrecy Act. For instance, it repeals the Consolidated Audit Trail database and includes a prohibition on central bank digital currencies.)

This kind of reform restores the proper balance—as provided by the Fourth Amendment—between Americans’ privacy rights and law enforcement’s ability to gather evidence to enforce laws. It would protect individuals’ financial privacy and improve federal agencies’ abilities to prosecute criminal activity rather than sift through millions of low-value reports. This kind of reform is long overdue.

You May Also Like

Editor's Pick

Clark Packard The US-China relationship is the most important and complex bilateral relationship in the world today. How these two superpowers interact is a...

Editor's Pick

Adam N. Michel Tax policy has taken on an outsized role in this year’s presidential campaign and was mentioned repeatedly in the recent presidential...

Editor's Pick

So the first Fed rate cut is behind us, and we are no longer in a “higher for longer” period, but in a new...

Editor's Pick

David Inserra Last week, Australia dropped its revised Combatting Misinformation and Disinformation Bill 2024, and it’s about two sandwiches short of a picnic. The...